Nov 6, 1997

Einstein was right - again! (Satellite observations of Black Holesconfirm frame-dragging effect 80 years after prediction)



Einstein was right...again!!!


Satellite observations of Black Holes confirm frame-dragging effect 80 years after prediction


frame dragging pix Sky&Telescope/Bergeron
November 6, 1997: The next time you feel like you're barely dragging along, blame relativity. You'll be stretching the point, but it appears that Einstein was right: space and time get pulled out of shape near a rotating body.


Einstein predicted the effect, called ``frame dragging,'' 80 years ago. Like many other aspects of Einstein's famous theories of relativity, it's so subtle that no conventional method could measure it.

Using recent observations by X-ray astronomy satellites, including NASA's Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer, a team of astronomers is announcing that they see evidence of frame dragging in disks of gas swirling around a black hole. The discovery will be announced today at a meeting of the High Energy Astrophysics Division of the American Astronomical Society in Estes Park, Colo., by Dr. Wei Cui of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and his colleagues, Dr. Nan Zhang, working at NASA's Marshall Space Flight Center, and Dr. Wan Chen of the University of Maryland in College Park.

Frame dragging is one of the last frontiers in relativity. More familiar and already proven are the conversion of mass into energy (as seen in atomic bombs and stars) and back, the Lorentz transformations that make objects near the speed of light grow thinner and heavier and stretch time, and the warping of space by gravity (as seen when light is bent by a massive object).

Einstein also predicted that the rotation of an object would alter space and time, dragging a nearby object out of position compared to predictions by the simpler math of Sir Isaac Newton.

The effect is incredibly small, about one part in a few trillion, which means that you have to look at something very massive, or build an instrument that is incredibly sensitive and put it in orbit.



Sir Isaac Newton

Sir Isaac Newton (right) could never have dreamed of the beauty and complexity of general relativity developed by Einstein (left), much less our ability to test and confirm its predictions using satellite technology - the orbits of which he could have understood quite well!!!

At the top of the story, an artist's concept of frame dragging shows a black hole's rotation twisting the fabric of space and time. As material crowds in through the accretion disk, some gases are squeezed outward to become superluminal jets. Although superluminal jets have been observed, the rest of the image is speculative since no one has observed a black hole in such detail.

Click on the image to get a 1622x1319 (637KB) JPG. If this image is used in print or on the web, please credit Joe Bergeron of Sky & Telescope magazine which will have an article on black hole spin by Joshua Roth in its December issue. For a TIFF file, go to:, pub folder. Log on as anonymous and use your e-mail address as the password. The files are bergeron.jpg and bergeron.tif. Animation of frame dragging will appear on NASA TV beginning at NOON EST on 11/6/97, and will repeat every 3 hours.

Learn More about Spinning Black Holes!!!

Cui, Zhang, and Chen followed the first path, looking at radiation coming from around black holes, once-massive stars compacted by an explosion to a diameter of a few kilometers. The gravitational field is so strong that everything - including light - goes in.

While we cannot see black holes directly, we can detect them by the light emitted by gas as it spirals inward to the black hole's point of no return, called the "event horizon". Like an unruly crowd jamming a stadium entrance, the gas becomes heated as it gets closer to the event horizon, and gives off radio waves, visible light, and - just before it disappears - x-rays.

The best place to look for black holes is in binary star systems where a normal star feeds the disk of accreting matter crowding its way into the accompanying black hole. Cui's team looked at two black holes, called GRS 1915+105 and GRO J1655-40, that also emit superluminal gas jets.



Check out the latest observations from GRO J1655-40, GRS 1915+105, and Cygnus X-3 at




The Multiwavelength Astronomy: Galactic Superluminal Jet Source WWW site


Learn More about the Earth Occultation Technique used by BATSE to monitor these sources


Earth Occulation with BATSE

In an earlier paper authored by Nan Zhang, the team measured the spin of these black holes based on the highest energy radiation which would also come from the innermost, and last possible orbit before the event horizon.

With the spin measured, the team turned to quasi-periodic oscillations, slight changes in the timing of the signals from the superluminal jets, and in other black holes.


precession of a rapidly spinning top
What they calculated is that the oscillations are caused by the frame dragging effect making the accretion disk precess. Precession is a very familiar effect, seen when a toy top both spins rapidly about its own axis, yet at the same time, executes a slower circular motion about the local vertical axis (as shown at left). This second circular motion is precession, and it's not only found in toy tops, but also in the motion of celestial bodies such as the Earth, or accreting disks around black holes in distant space.

What Cui, Zhang, and Chen found was a precession far greater than a simple mechanical effect could explain. In the case of GRO J1655-40, which is about 7 times more massive than our sun and spinning near the maximum allowed rate, the accretion disk precesses 300 times a second! GRS 1915+105, also spinning near the maximum rate, the disk precesses a mere 67 times per second.

Two other black holes have very slow and variable precession rates, indicating that their accretion disks have not settled into a stable formation.

Someone observing a safe distance away from the black hole binary system would see the accretion disk appear to wobble like a top out of balance.

Zhang said the team is confident of its findings because spin calculations made in this work give the same answer as earlier spin calculations using a different approach.


Gravity Probe B - Artist's concept
And speaking of different approaches, what of the second method for measuring frame dragging?

Zhang said that it remains as important as ever. NASA is developing it as Gravity Probe-B, a satellite containing precision gyroscopes inside a liquid helium bath. GP-B will point at a selected star, and sensitive instruments will measure how much the gyros precess after conventional effects are nullified. The leftover effects should provide a precise measure of frame dragging.

Zhang pointed out that the Rossi satellite observations are not a controlled experiment. The exact mass of the star and other effects around it are not known with great detail. Gravity Probe-B, though, will be the controlled experiment which gives physicists the precision they need for filling it blank spots in our understanding of how the universe works.




return to top of page

Author: Dave Dooling, Dr. Nan Zhang
Curator: Bryan Walls
NASA Official: John M. Horack